Condo Pet Eviction – Court Rejects Human Rights Claim and Clarifies What Evidence of Disability Should be Provided
Condo Pet Eviction – Court Rejects Human Rights Claim and Clarifies What Evidence of Disability Should be Provided
Submitted By: admin on Nov 24, 2015
Many condominium corporations have restrictions or a prohibition on pets. Boards and managers feel an obligation to enforce the provisions in their legal documents but are uncertain about the steps they can take when disabilities and human rights are raised. A recent court case clarifies the options corporations have when a resident claims that a disability requires that they have a pet.
In SCC No. 89 v Dominelli, the Court determined that the pet owner had failed to provide evidence that established that she had a disability. “To establish a ‘mental disability’, a diagnosis of some recognised mental disability, or at least a ‘working diagnosis or articulation of clinically-significant symptoms’ that has ‘specificity and substance’ is required”. The Court also confirmed that the condominium corporation was entitled to seek additional information about the pet-owner’s disability.
The Court ruled against the pet owner and awarded the corporation damages in the amount of $47,000, including disbursements and HST to be paid within 20 days of the order, plus interest. In addition to not being able to keep their dog, they had to pay for both their own and the condominium corporation’s legal expenses.
Crossbridge has the property management industry’s only Ontario Power Authority sanctioned Embedded Energy Manager
Crossbridge’s clients have realized approximately $1 million of new savings each year
Since mid-2010 we have facilitated annual utility savings to our clients totaling nearly $8.0 million
We have also urged government departments and agencies to address inequities in utility billing, evaluated new products and services, developed new municipal codes and established industry best protocols for our clients (e.g. Electrical vehicle charging in condominiums)